Episode 128 - Bally vs. Stern: The Definitive Answer

Stern vs. Bally showdown reveals near-identical quality averages despite perceptual differences.

Wedgehead Pinball hosts a detailed comparative analysis of Stern Electronics (1977-1982, 29 games) versus Bally solid-state machines (same era, 41 games). Using Pinside and Pinball Ranker data, they find both manufacturers virtually tied in average quality (7.32 vs 7.34 on Pinside; 225 vs 227 average rank on Pinball Ranker), though hosts debate whether Stern's average is stronger despite having more truly bad games. The episode examines best and worst lineups, gameplay philosophy differences, and operator value propositions.

Highlights

• Stern Electronics produced 29 solid-state titles between 1977-1982
• Bally produced 41 solid-state titles in the same 1977-1982 period
• Pinside average ranking for Stern is 7.32 out of 10; Bally is 7.34
• Pinball Ranker average position for Stern games is 225 (out of 474 ranked games); Bally is 227
• Stern has more truly bad games in their lineup; Bally's worst games are better but more numerous mediocre titles
• Bally recycled playfields across games (e.g., Bobby Orr and Mata Hari share same playfield)
• George Christian is 'the GOAT of the era' for Bally design
• Bally drop targets are less reliable than Stern drop targets
• Solid-state games offer better multiplayer and improvisational gameplay than modern LCD games
• Even bad solid-state machines have operator value at lower price points to diversify venue lineups