The Toy Pit

The Toy Pit at 3827 N College Ave in Indianapolis is a large buy–sell–trade toy and collectibles shop specializing in vintage action figures, comics, vinyl and nostalgia from the ’70s to today, serving collectors and families alike. Locally praised for its wide selection and friendly staff, the store maintains an active social presence and receives frequent positive reviews on Yelp and social media. The shop also hosts a small pinball area with eight machines; the current machine identifiers provided are 3738, 3673, 3415, 3255, 3167, 3226 and 3022, making it a fun stop for pinball fans visiting the Indy State Fairgrounds area.