The Toy Pit
Indianapolis, IN 46205
Pins:
8
The Toy Pit
3827 N College Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46205
Last updated:
October 10, 2025
Data quality:
Stale
Pinball machines:
8
Collection Size:
Medium Collection
The Toy Pit at 3827 N College Ave in Indianapolis is a sprawling 12,000+ sq ft toy emporium near the Indiana State Fairgrounds that buys, sells and trades vintage and modern collectibles—action figures, vinyl, comics and more—and features a cozy arcade corner with eight pinball machines, delivering a treasure‑hunt shopping experience with friendly, knowledgeable staff and a constantly rotating selection of nostalgia and pop‑culture finds.
This Week in Pinball
Weekly pinball news and features, plus a few other things. Join for free.
Game List
Arcade types
No items found.
